Skip to content
richbay.ai
PlaygroundsCasesLearnTools
For Teams
richbay.ai

Practice better AI judgment with real outputs, evidence, and repeatable methods.

Explore

  • Playgrounds
  • Cases

Resources

  • Learn
  • Tools

RichBay

  • For Teams
  • About
  • Privacy

© 2026 Richbay

RichBay.ai is independent and is not affiliated with or endorsed by the model providers or companies referenced on this site.

RichBay method · reviewed 2026-08-26

How to judge an AI answer without guessing the model

A repeatable checklist for moving from “this sounds good” to “this is usable for the task.”

1. Define success first

Write the constraints, required evidence, and acceptable uncertainty before model fluency can change your standard.

2. Separate claims from presentation

A polished answer may contain weak claims; a plain answer may be correct and useful. Review those dimensions separately.

3. Trace evidence

For factual claims, prefer current primary sources and confirm that each source actually supports the nearby claim.

4. Locate uncertainty

Ask what is not observed, what could confound the result, and what new evidence would change the decision.

5. Decide for this task

Choose the answer that best satisfies this prompt and risk level. Do not turn one example into a global model ranking.

Use the method on real outputs

The budget case tests auditability, the pilot case tests evidence boundaries, and the conversion case tests causal uncertainty.

  • Budget math case
  • Pilot evidence case
  • Conversion uncertainty case
Practice with a blind challenge

External methodology reference: NIST AI Risk Management Framework. The guide is educational and should be adapted for domain-specific risk.